Court Slams SERAP For ‘False Alarm,’ Orders N100m Payback To DSS
In a stinging rebuke, the Federal Capital Territory High Court in Abuja has ruled that the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project defamed the Department of State Services, awarding a hefty N100 million in damages against the civic group.
Delivering judgment, Justice Yusuf Halilu held that SERAP’s publication painted DSS operatives in a false and damaging light, accusing them of unlawful conduct and harassment—claims the court found to be unsubstantiated.
The judge zeroed in on the crux of the matter: whether defamation was proven. He noted that the DSS’s evidence stood firm, largely unchallenged by SERAP, thereby strengthening the agency’s case.
According to the court, defamation, whether libel or slander, remains a serious legal offence when a statement exposes individuals to ridicule or contempt.
Justice Halilu stressed that once a damaging publication is proven, liability follows.
Also Read:ADC Implodes: Courts, Chaos Stall Congresses Nationwide
Citing exhibits tendered before the court, the judge affirmed that the contentious publication did indeed exist and carried defamatory weight, despite not explicitly naming the DSS officers involved.
“I have taken judicial notice of their features,” he said, ruling that the physical descriptions in the report clearly pointed to the claimants.
The court found that the narrative pushed by SERAP suggested that DSS operatives unlawfully stormed its office and intimidated staff, an impression deemed harmful to the officers’ professional standing.
“Such allegations should not be casually attributed,” the judge declared, warning of the psychological and reputational toll such claims can inflict.
Beyond the financial penalty, the court ordered SERAP to issue public apologies across national newspapers and television platforms, marking a significant reputational setback for the advocacy group.
The case, filed in October 2024 by the DSS and two operatives, Sarah John and Gabriel Ogundele; stemmed from allegations that DSS officials invaded SERAP’s Abuja office the previous month.
While the DSS consistently denied the claims, SERAP insisted the incident followed its petition to President Bola Tinubu over alleged corruption in the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited and rising fuel prices.
The court’s ruling now draws a firm legal line, saying that advocacy must not cross into defamation, or come prepared to pay the price.
